I Would Appreciate Your Thoughts

[ChrisB1972]

Hi

I am looking to purchase my first X-Type. I want All Wheel Drive so it will be a V6 Petrol.

I want some advice as to which do people feel is the more reliable engine and gearbox?

Should I go for a 2.5 or for the 3.0 Litre? Are they both Jag units or is one a Ford in disguise?

Then should I go for an Auto or a manual 'box?

I should add I currently drive an Octavia Tdi with the DSG gearbox, but a new job means I will be cutting my annual mileage massively.

Your thoughts are very much appreciated

Chris

[Old Peter]

Hi Chris,

The x type is much maligned, especially by those who have neither owned or driven one.  The engines on most modern cars are not necessarily made by the company with the badge on the front, as neither are many of the parts.  Car manufactures buy their parts from specialist companies such as Bosch for electrical bits and other similar companies for other parts.

When the X type was designed and produced it was in the ownership of Ford, which was not a bad thing, as Ford technology is well respected in the Industry.

The design is all Jaguar although the Ford input was basically the body pan/chassis which came from a cut down Mondeo, and the engines are Ford, whose engines also power the Aston Martin, the Morgan, and a few other cars.

The X type 3.0 litre AWD is a very good engine and was very popular in the USA , and I used to have  a 2.5 litre AWD which was a great car to drive and described by a journalist reviewer as "nippy".

The gearboxes on both models are good, and although I prefer the Auto Gearbox, my x type had the manual, with which I never had a problem.

You just test drive one of each and see which you prefer.

Regards

Peter. 

[ChrisB1972]

1 hour ago, Old Peter said:

Hi Chris,

The x type is much maligned, especially by those who have neither owned or driven one.  The engines on most modern cars are not necessarily made by the company with the badge on the front, as neither are many of the parts.  Car manufactures buy their parts from specialist companies such as Bosch for electrical bits and other similar companies for other parts.

When the X type was designed and produced it was in the ownership of Ford, which was not a bad thing, as Ford technology is well respected in the Industry.

The design is all Jaguar although the Ford input was basically the body pan/chassis which came from a cut down Mondeo, and the engines are Ford, whose engines also power the Aston Martin, the Morgan, and a few other cars.

The X type 3.0 litre AWD is a very good engine and was very popular in the USA , and I used to have  a 2.5 litre AWD which was a great car to drive and described by a journalist reviewer as "nippy".

The gearboxes on both models are good, and although I prefer the Auto Gearbox, my x type had the manual, with which I never had a problem.

You just test drive one of each and see which you prefer.

Regards

Peter. 

Thanks Peter

Having got used to an Auto I would prefer one, I think.

Do both engines have a timing chain? I've read so many different things about them I'm lost

Chris

[Old Peter]

Timing chains on both, Chris.

Sorry for the delay in replying  ---  the satellite connection is poor in the North sea.

Regards,

Peter.

 

 

[ChrisB1972]

9 hours ago, Old Peter said:

Timing chains on both, Chris.

Sorry for the delay in replying  ---  the satellite connection is poor in the North sea.

Regards,

Peter.

 

 

No problem at all Peter

Thanks for the reply.

My first choice would definitely be a 3.0 SE Auto but I'm finding it hard to find one in my price bracket.

I'm going to look at a 2.5 SE Auto tomorrow morning. Hopefully I'll be the owner of an X-Type the next time we speak :)

Chris

[Andy X400 3.0]

I have a 3.0 SE Auto and it's fantastic , very smooth and responsive. Regards , Andy .